Precision, Accuracy, and Aliasing of Sea Ice Thickness from Multiple Platforms
收藏资源简介:
The sea ice community seeks an integrated-instrument approach to measure sea ice thickness from its components of draft, freeboard, and surface elevation (including snow loads). Current bias error estimates are included in archives. However, many issues are not yet accounted for. Hence, it is very timely to ask the science question: What are the different types of uncertainty which impact the measurement accuracy of sea ice thickness, its distribution, and resulting volume? This project developed a collection of "demonstration papers" to identify and support solutions for the integration of data sets across multiple scales. The essence of the problem comes down to the interpretation of data collected by one instrument with one footprint size versus another instrument with a different footprint. Plots of sea ice thickness frequency distribution serve as a “Rosetta Stone” within the sea ice community to communicate sea ice thickness information between scales. Spatial aliasing distorts this communication across the scales by introducing false peaks, like garbled language, into our Rosetta-Stone communicator. The problem introduces a resolution error as a function of the size (length scale) and shape (waveform) of an instrument’s footprint. We are finding that instruments with measurement footprints which exceed sea ice features incorporate spatial aliasing into their thickness records. Aliasing occurs whenever deep narrow features are smoothened into wider shallower features. The integrated volume is not initially impacted and hence the problem is accepted as a small second-order effect for individual instruments. But the conserved ice volume is not an archived data value. The archived data values are thickness and associated frequency distributions which are important model parameters for heat fluxes at the air-sea interface. The problem is only now becoming relevant as geolocation errors diminish to the benefit of coincident measurement campaigns. Specifically, aliasing increases when we combine measurements from different instruments at different scales. This is a problem that needs to be addressed because sea ice scientists are being asked by non-scientists and policy makers for higher data quality so that they can make critical decisions about global human activities. Spatial aliasing is a ubiquitous problem that is not limited to sea ice thickness nor is it limited to instrument measurements. The problem becomes most pronounced for strongly non-Gaussian (skewed) distributions such as sea ice and snow thickness. In particular, cases with strong bi-modal distribution can incur resolution errors which impact large-scale sea ice volume estimates.
海冰学界亟需一套集成仪器观测方案,通过海冰吃水(draft)、干舷(freeboard)及表面高程(含积雪载荷)等组分开展海冰厚度测量。当前的偏差误差估算结果已纳入存档数据,但仍有诸多未被考虑的问题。因此,当下提出该科学问题恰逢其时:哪些不同类型的不确定性会影响海冰厚度测量精度、厚度分布及由此得到的海冰体积?本项目产出了一系列“示范论文”,旨在识别并支撑跨多尺度数据集融合的解决方案。该问题的核心在于如何解读不同足迹(footprint)尺寸的仪器所采集的观测数据。海冰厚度频率分布图谱可作为海冰学界的“罗塞塔石碑”,实现不同尺度下海冰厚度信息的互通。空间混叠(spatial aliasing)会通过向该“罗塞塔石碑”式的信息互通渠道引入虚假峰值(如同语言乱码),扭曲跨尺度的信息传递。该问题体现为与仪器足迹的尺寸(长度尺度)和形状(波形)相关的分辨率误差。研究发现,当仪器的观测足迹覆盖海冰特征尺度时,其厚度记录中会引入空间混叠。每当狭窄深厚的海冰特征被平滑为宽浅特征时,便会发生混叠现象。初始情况下,集成后的海冰体积不受明显影响,因此该问题被视作单台仪器观测中的次要小效应。但存档数据中并未保存海冰体积的守恒量,存档数据仅包含厚度及相关频率分布——而这些均为气-海界面热通量的重要模型参数。随着定位误差的降低,同步观测计划的优势得以显现,该问题也逐渐受到关注。具体而言,当结合不同尺度下多台仪器的观测数据时,空间混叠效应会加剧。这一问题亟待解决,因为非科研人员与政策制定者正要求海冰科学家提供更高质量的数据,以支撑关乎全球人类活动的重大决策。空间混叠是一个普遍存在的问题,不仅局限于海冰厚度测量,也不限于仪器观测场景。对于海冰与积雪厚度这类强非高斯(偏态)分布而言,该问题尤为突出。特别是当出现强双峰分布时,可能会产生分辨率误差,进而影响大尺度海冰体积估算结果。



