Table 1_Barriers and facilitators in implementing advance care planning for frail older patients acutely admitted to geriatric hospital units: a nested qualitative study.docx

BackgroundAppropriate communication with patients is increasingly crucial in a growing elderly population to prevent both over- and undertreatment. Advance care planning (ACP) is recognized as a valuable communication process for patients, their relatives and healthcare professionals that facilitates future care and medical decision-making. Despite its importance, the uptake remains low, particularly among frail, older patients in hospitals.
MethodsThis qualitative substudy is nested within a cluster randomized controlled trial. Data collection involved eight semi-structured interviews conducted in acute geriatric hospital units receiving our implementation support program, along with informal data from interactions with the units during the implementation process. The aim was to explore healthcare professionals' perspectives on the barriers and facilitators to ACP implementation and their experiences with the implementation support program. A semi-structured interview guide was used. The data was analyzed using content analysis.
ResultsFactors influencing ACP implementation were identified at three levels: a) the organizational level, b) the national level, and c) the clinical level. Participants recognized the critical role of timing, context, and patients' capacity. However, there was meaningful opportunities for ACP conversations in acute geriatric units. Overall, the experiences underscored the complex interplay of individual motivation and interest, organizational support, prioritization, available time and resources, and systemic factors that influence the integration of ACP into clinical practice, as well as the fact that research can act as both a barrier and a facilitator in implementation efforts.
DiscussionThis study illustrates the significant challenges in implementing ACP in acute hospital care. Despite a generally positive perception of ACP, its implementation was hindered by barriers such as overwhelming workload, production-oriented healthcare, the biomedical model, and lack of prioritization. These factors creates a cycle where short-term demands overshadow preventive and patient-centered interventions, limiting their perceived and documented benefits. Breaking this cycle will likely require targeted investment in the implementation of complex interventions.
Trial registrationClinicalTrials.gov, Identifier NCT05681585.