Evaluation of PE5 Entries on the Human Proteome Project Target List

One aim of the international Human Proteome Organization
(HUPO)
Human Proteome Project (HPP) is to obtain high-confidence translation
evidence for every human protein-coding gene established in its target
list of 19,433 entries based on the protein-coding genes from Ensembl-GENCODE.
However, 76 are annotated in UniProtKB (as of release 2024_06) with
PE5, indicating skepticism in the protein’s existence from
a manual curator, so it is unclear if these entries belong in the
HPP target list. Here, we review these 76 entries by assembling evidence
from the literature, reference databases, and genome alignments with
other species to conclude whether these entries should be freed from
their PE5 status to become annotated with PE1–4 in UniProtKB.
We find that 17 of these have credible translation evidence and therefore
should be upgraded to PE1. Another 15 lack translation evidence but
have transcription evidence, the evolutionary hallmarks of protein-coding
genes, and are presumed to produce functional proteins. 41 have no
translational or transcriptional evidence, although they still bear
the evolutionary hallmarks of protein-coding genes; currently, it
remains unclear if these are protein-coding, so their representation
becomes a matter of policy. Only 3 entries still seem best categorized
as PE5 and excluded from the HUPO-HPP target list.