Comparison between pharyngeal flap surgery and sphincteroplasty: nasometric and aerodynamic analysis

PURPOSE: to compare the effect of pharyngeal flap surgery and sphincteroplasty on hypernasality and velopharyngeal closure in velopharyngeal insufficiency management, by means of instrumental assessment. METHODS: thirty patients with repaired cleft palate±lip, submitted to surgical treatment for velopharyngeal insufficiency (15 pharyngeal flap and 15 sphincteroplasty) were evaluated before and, at least, 1 year after surgery. Hypernasality was estimated by means of nasalance scores (acoustic correlate of nasality) obtained by nasometry considering a cutoff score of 27%. Velopharyngeal closure was determined by the velopharyngeal area measurement. Nasalance scores were obtained by nasometry, during the reading of a set of 5 sentences containing exclusively oral sounds, considering the cutoff value of 27%. Velopharyngeal area was provided by the measurement of velopharyngeal area by means of pressure-flow technique and was classified as: 0 to 4.9 mm2=adequate; 5 to 19.9 mm2=borderline and ≥20mm2 inadequate. Differences between the two techniques were accepted as significant when p