Table E- 0 - 4 in Saidabad Water Treatment Plant Project, Phase III

Table E-0-4: Three Alternate Locations Considered for the Raw Water Intake for Saidabad phase III (new table) SI. No.Water QualityProne to the discharge of Wastewater and Solid WasteCapital and Operation CostsLand AcquisitionImplementation ConstraintMultiple independent intakesRaw water transmission linesPumping headSecured Water Supply1PoorYesLess compared to 2 optionsNot requiredBetter than other 2 options for one season onlyLess securedLess compared to other 2 optionsNew arrangement required to setLess2GoodNoHighest to other 2 options30% more land acquisition would be required which would be costlierLand acquisition will be a challengeLess securedHighest to other 2 options15% more pumping head compared to the Haria optionLes3GoodNoLess compared to Option 2 (4km shorter TL than Option 2)Less costly than Option 2Major portion will be within the Right of Way of Roads and Highways Department33% water security will be increasedLess compared to Option 2 (4km shorter RWTL than Option 2)15% less pumping head compared to the Option 233% more