Data for Ross-Hellauer & Horbach_2024_'Additional experiments required_ A scoping review of recent evidence on key aspects of Open Peer Review'

20th Jan 2024, Tony Ross-Hellauer & Serge P.J.M Horbach

This spreadsheet contains details of the database searching and assessment of literature for inclusion in the paper "Additional experiments required: A scoping review of recent evidence on key aspects of Open Peer Review" by Tony Ross-Hellauer and Serge P.J.M Horbach

Description of content of each sheet:

1. Scopus: All literature found via searching Scopus using the search terms in (4. Queries/process), search performed on 19th May 2022 by TRH - 356 results2. WoS: All literature found via searching Web of Science using the search terms in (4. Queries/process), search performed on 19th May 2022 by SH - 296 results3. Initial merge: Combined Scopus/WoS results - 651 results4. De-dup:  De-deduplicating Scopus/WoS results on DOI, 273 duplicate rows found and removed, 378 unique rows remain 5. Screening: Combined results of independent title/abstract screening by both reviewers (164 studies judged relevant by at least one reviewer)6. Full-text/data-extraction: All 164 relevant Scopus/WoS  results, after title/abstract screening. Contains results of (1) decision to include after full-text screening; (2) data extraction for relevant studies7. Snowballing: Results for all relevant results identified via "snowballing" using methods described in manuscript8. Web search: Results for all relevant results identified via web searching using methods described in manuscript9. Final list all included studies: Final results for all 57 included studies (note, includes 5 results relevant only for Open Participation (OP))10. Final list (no OP): Final results for all 52 studies relevant only to Open Identities and/or Open Reports and included in the main text of the manuscript.