Evaluating summary methods for multi-locus species tree estimation in the presence of incomplete lineage sorting

Species tree estimation is complicated by processes, such as gene duplication and loss and incomplete lineage sorting (ILS), that cause discordance between gene trees and the species tree. Furthermore, while concatenation, a traditional approach to tree estimation, has excellent performance under many conditions, the expectation is that the best accuracy will be obtained through the use of species tree estimation methods that are specifically designed to address gene tree discordance. In this paper, we report on a study to evaluate MP-EST – one of the most popular species tree estimation methods designed to address ILS – as well as concatenation under maximum likelihood, the greedy consensus, and two supertree methods (MRP and MRL). Our study shows that several factors impact the absolute and relative accuracy of methods, including the number of gene trees, the accuracy of the estimated gene trees, and the amount of ILS. Concatenation can be more accurate than the best summary methods i...