The species richness-productivity relationship varies among regions and productivity estimates, but not with spatial resolution

The relationship between species richness and productivity (SRPR) has been a long-studied and hotly debated topic in ecology. Different studies have reported different results with variable shapes (i.e. unimodal, linear) and directions (i.e. positive, negative) of SRPRs depending on spatial grain (i.e. size of sampling unit for species richness), productivity estimates, and study extent. In this study, we quantified the effect of multiple estimates of productivity (aboveground, belowground and total biomass, and various measures of soil fertility) on species richness across three spatial grains (0.04 m2, 1 m2, and 25 m2) across temperate grasslands from two regions in Central Europe. We analyzed SRPR in each of the two regional datasets separately, as well as the two datasets pooled together. Our results have revealed that differences caused by spatial grain were unexpectedly small, and the direction of the SRPR was consistent within each productivity estimate, but differed between regi...