Four Polymorphs of Methyl Paraben: Structural Relationships and Relative Energy Differences

Four polymorphic forms of methyl paraben (methyl 4-hydroxybenzoate, 1), denoted 1-I (melting point 126 °C), 1-III (109 °C), 1-107 (107
°C), and 1-112 (112 °C), have
been investigated by thermomicroscopy, infrared spectroscopy, and
X-ray crystallography. The crystal structures of the metastable forms 1-III, 1-107, and 1-112 have been determined. All polymorphs contain the
same O–H···OC connected catemer motif,
but the geometry of the resulting H-bonded chain is different in each
form. The Z′ = 3 structure of 1-I (stable form; space group Cc) contains local symmetry elements. The crystal packing of each of
the four known crystal structures of 1 was compared with
the crystal structures of 12 chemical analogues. Close two-dimensional
relationships exist between 1-112 and a
form of methyl 4-aminobenzoate and between 1-107 and dimethyl terephthalate. The lattice
energies of the four methyl paraben structures have been calculated
with a range of methods based on ab initio electronic calculations
on either the crystal or single molecule. This shows that the differences
in the induction energy of the different hydrogen-bonded chain geometries
have a significant effect on relative lattice energies, but that conformational
energy, repulsion, dispersion, and electrostatic also contribute.