Data for: Of the first five US states with food waste bans, Massachusetts alone has reduced landfill waste

Diverting food waste from landfills is crucial to reducing emissions and meeting Paris Agreement targets. Between 2014 and 2024, nine US states banned commercial waste generators---such as grocery chains---from landfilling food waste, expecting a 10–15% waste reduction. However, no evaluation of these bans exists. We compile a comprehensive waste dataset covering 36 US states between 1996 and 2019 to evaluate the first five implemented state-level bans. Contrary to policymakers' expectations, we can reject aggregate waste reductions higher than 4.0%, and cannot reject a zero-null aggregate effect. Moreover, we cannot reject a zero-null effect for any other state except Massachusetts, which gradually achieved a 13.1% reduction. Our findings reveal the need to reassess food waste bans, using Massachusetts as a benchmark for success.