Improving dryland seedling recruitment using fungicide seed coatings

The success of seed-based restoration in dryland regions of the world is
often low or sporadic, with most mortality occurring between germination
and emergence. Fungal pathogenesis is one process that may reduce seedling
emergence and limit restoration success. Our objective was to determine
whether fungicide seed coatings constitute an economically viable strategy
for increasing emergence by reducing fungal pathogenesis and mortality. We
performed an experiment across two sites and three years, using bluebunch
wheatgrass (Pseudoroegneria spicata) as a model species. We found that
fungicide coatings increased germination by 8.8% and emergence by 54.0% on
average compared to the control. A cost analysis indicated that the
fungicide coating was economically viable with an average estimated
effective cost reduction of 18.8% under the study conditions. There was a
strong interaction (P < 0.001) between the effects of the fungicide
coating, site, and year on emergence. The fungicide coating increased
emergence compared to the control in five of the six sites and years, with
the effect ranging from a 33.7% decrease (P = 0.042) to a 150.9% increase
(P = 0.004). The observed interaction was likely related to the effect of
the hydrothermal microsite environment on disease severity. In the site
and year that the fungicide coating performed worse than the control,
prolonged periods of exceptionally low soil moisture may have reduced
disease severity through a variety of individual and community scale
mechanisms. Overall, these results indicate that fungicide seed coatings
have the potential to improve dryland restoration efforts.