Data for "A wolf in sheep’s clothing: predatory fish have convergent consumptive effects but divergent predation-risk effects" (Ecosphere 2022).

We performed two field mesocosm experiments with free-roaming and caged predators to explore post-colonization interactions of the chemically-camouflaged, large-gaped, ambush predator, pirate perch (<i>Aphredoderus sayanus</i>), active, large-gaped green sunfish (<i>Lepomis cyanellus</i>), and active, small-gaped golden topminnow (<i>Fundulus chrysotus</i>), with larval gray treefrogs (<i>Hyla chrysoscelis</i>) and mole salamanders (<i>Ambystoma talpoideum</i>). We examined consumptive and predation-risk effects of each predator on amphibian mortality, growth rates, tail morphology, and facultative paedomorphosis.