Data from: High levels of genetic structure and striking phenotypic variability in a sexually dimorphic suckermouth catfish from the African Highveld

Uncovering biological diversity to more accurately understand diversity patterns, and ultimately the processes driving diversification is important not only from an evolutionary, but also a conservation perspective. This is particularly pertinent in Africa’s rivers in which overall diversity, as well as how it arose, is poorly understood in comparison to lacustrine environments. Here we investigate population divergence in the sexually dimorphic suckermouth catfish species Chiloglanis anoterus (Crass, 1960) from the African Highveld, in which we observe striking variability in exaggerated male caudal fins across its range. As this trait is likely to be indirect evidence for sexual selection by female choice, a mechanism that has been shown to increase species diversity in different taxa, we used an integrated approach to test if current diversity in this species is underestimated. Results based on phylogenetic inference, population genetics and geometric morphometrics indicate that the recognised species C. anoterus represents five distinct lineages that may be considered confirmed candidate species. We suggest that diversification in these highland catfish has been facilitated through geographic isolation in upper river catchments, and that sexual selection through female choice has likely driven variation in male caudal fin morphology. In contrast to the relatively large range size of the currently recognised species (C. anoterus), our findings highlight highly restricted ranges of the lineages identified here indicating that these highland habitats may harbour higher levels of endemic diversity than previously thought.