Additive effects of plant chemotype, mutualistic ants and predators on aphid performance and survival

1. Cascading effects in ecological systems acting across three or more trophic levels can be either of a resource-based (bottom-up) or natural enemy-based (top-down) nature. But, due to their complexity these effects are often considered separately and their relative strength, acting simultaneously, remains unknown.
2. In a semi-natural field experiment using tansy (Tanacetum vulgare L.) and the specialised tansy aphid Metopeurum fuscoviride Stroyan as a model system, we compared the effects of four distinct plant chemotypes (i.e. bottom-up), defined by the bouquet of their volatile terpenoids, on aphid population dynamics by manipulating the presence/absence of mutualistic ants and presence/absence of naturally-occurring predators (i.e. top-down).
3. Predators reduced aphid abundance and colony survival but did not reduce initial growth rate due to a time lag until predators arrived on the plants. Ants directly benefited initial aphid growth rates and abundance, even in the absence o...