Final publication recommendation by Ra and Re for those manuscripts, for which an Ra and an Re gave identical ratings on three evaluation criteria (n = 24).

In the table, three final publication recommendations where Ra made a more favorable recommendation than Re are shown in bold.Notes.§Response categories: (1) excellent, (2) good, (3) fair, and (4) poor.$ Response categories: (Accept) yes, without alterations, (Minor) yes, after minor alterations, (Major) yes, after major alterations.