Kinetics-Based State Definitions for Discrete Binding Conformations of T4 L99A in MD via Markov State Modeling

As a model system, the binding pocket of the L99A mutant of T4 lysozyme has been the subject of numerous computational free energy studies. However, previous studies have failed to fully sample and account for the observed changes in the binding pocket of T4 L99A upon binding of a congeneric ligand series, limiting the accuracy of results. In this work, we resolve the closed, intermediate, and open states for T4 L99A previously reported in experiment in MD and establish definitions for these states based on the dynamics of the system. From this analysis, we arrive at two primary conclusions. First, assignment of simulation trajectories into discrete states should not be done simply based on RMSD to crystal structures as this can result in misassignment of states. Second, the different metastable conformations studied here need to be carefully treated, as we estimate the time scales for conformational interconversion to be on the order of 102 to 103 nsfar longer than time scales for typical binding calculations. We conclude with a discussion on the need to develop enhanced sampling methods to generally account for significant changes in protein conformation due to relatively small ligand perturbations.