Replication Data for: The Law Behind Dispute Onset: How Legal Uncertainty Drives Maritime Boundary Disputes

These are the replication files for the manuscript entitled "The Law Behind Dispute Onset: How Legal Uncertainty Drives Maritime Boundary Disputes" (Yüksel, U. (2024). The Law Behind Dispute Onset: How Legal Uncertainty Drives Maritime Boundary Disputes. Journal of Conflict Resolution, Online First). https://doi.org/10.1177/00220027241305076). They consist of two .RData files and a script that works with them to produce the figures and tables reported in the manuscript. ABSTRACT of the article: "The making of international law through multilateral conventions and adjudication often leads to periods of legal uncertainty, times in which there are alternative rules and divergent views on how they ought to be applied to particular cases. I argue that legal uncertainty gives states opportunities and incentives to formulate excessive unilateral claims, thus making disputes more likely to arise. I illustrate my argument with a comprehensive analysis of maritime boundary disputes in the aftermath of the Second World War. In this period, the law regulating maritime boundary-making has been marked by varying degrees of uncertainty due to different rules and interpretations proffered by various multilateral and judicial lawmaking attempts. I find strong evidence that high legal uncertainty is associated with an increased probability of dispute onset. The analysis calls for an important rethinking of the impact of legalization on international affairs, both in maritime boundary-making and in other issues areas."