Data from: Tips and nodes are complimentary not competing approaches to the calibration of molecular clocks
收藏资源简介:
Molecular clock methodology provides the best means of establishing evolutionary timescales, the accuracy and precision of which remain reliant on calibration, traditionally based on fossil constraints on clade (node) ages. Tip calibration has been developed to obviate undesirable aspects of node calibration, including the need for maximum age constraints that are invariably very difficult to justify. Instead, tip calibration incorporates fossil species as dated tips alongside living relatives, potentially improving the accuracy and precision of divergence time estimates. We demonstrate that tip calibration yields node calibrations that violate fossil evidence, contributing to unjustifiably young and ancient age estimates, less precise and (presumably) accurate than conventional node calibration. However, we go on to show that node and tip calibrations are complementary, producing meaningful age estimates, with node minima enforcing realistic ages and fossil tips interacting with node calibrations to objectively define maximum age constraints on clade ages. Together, tip and node calibrations may yield evolutionary timescales that are better justified, more precise and accurate than either calibration strategy can achieve alone.
分子钟方法(Molecular clock methodology)是确立进化时间尺度的最优手段,但其准确性与精确性仍依赖于校准环节。传统校准通常基于支系(节点)年代的化石约束。末端校准(tip calibration)的提出,旨在规避节点校准的各类不良缺陷——包括往往极难论证合理性的最大年代约束需求。相较于节点校准,末端校准将化石物种作为带有年代标注的末端类群,与现生亲缘类群一同纳入校准,有望提升分化时间估算的准确性与精确性。本研究表明,末端校准所得到的节点校准结果会违背化石证据,导致不合理的过年轻或过古老的年代估算结果,其精确性与(据推测)准确性均不如传统节点校准。不过,本研究进一步证实,节点校准与末端校准二者具有互补性:节点最小年代约束可限定合理的年代范围,而化石末端类群与节点校准结合,则可客观定义支系年代的最大年代约束,最终得到具有实际意义的年代估算结果。综上,末端校准与节点校准结合,可得到比单一校准策略更具论证合理性、精确性与准确性的进化时间尺度。



