Will stumps from forest thinning and other standing deadwood provide habitat for saproxylic beetles if felling stumps on clearcuts are harvested?

Increased level of stump harvest on clearcuts is expected due to growing demand for bioenergy. For saproxylic species, this will reduce habitat supply. Negative effects on populations may be buffered by alternative deadwood habitats, especially stumps after forest thinning. We investigated clearcuts and mature forest to see whether such stumps or other standing deadwood could host saproxylic beetles that occur in clear-felling stumps. The study was conducted in boreal Sweden, on clearcuts 3–14 years after harvest and in mature forests. Beetles were sampled from the bark of spruce, pine and birch, from stumps after clear-felling, stumps after thinning, snags within forests and high-stumps on clearcuts. Beta diversity differed significantly between deadwood types, but not tree species. The stumps after thinning had a species poor assemblage compared to other deadwood. Abundance of common species was higher in deadwood on clearcuts compared to forests, and higher in snags than in stumps. We conclude that stumps after thinning and other standing deadwood will not buffer habitat loss from increased stump harvest for species inhabiting stumps on clearcuts, because these communities require sun-exposed habitats. Within mature managed forests, improving the quality and diversity of deadwood will be important for increasing the diversity of saproxylic beetle communities.