Replication data for: Age and Tenure of the Justices and Productivity of the U.S. Supreme Court: Are Term Limits Necessary?
收藏资源简介:
This Article examines the relationship between the productivity of the U.S. Supreme Court and the age and tenure of the Supreme Court Justices. The motivation for this Article is the Supreme Court Renewal Act of 2005 (SCRA) and other recent proposals to impose term limits for Supreme Court Justices. The authors of the SCRA and others suggest that term limits are necessary because, inter alia, increased longevity and terms of service of the Justices have resulted in a decline in the productivity of the Court as measured by the number of cases accepted for review and the number of opinions issued per term. On the whole, the empirical findings of this Article do not provide clear support for this assertion.
本文考察美国最高法院(U.S. Supreme Court)的办案效率与大法官年龄及任职时长之间的关联。本文的研究动因源于2005年《最高法院改革法案》(Supreme Court Renewal Act of 2005, SCRA)以及近期其他针对最高法院大法官设置任职期限限制的提案。该法案的起草者及其他提案支持者认为,设置任职期限限制实属必要,理由包括:大法官寿命延长与任职时长增加,会导致最高法院办案效率下滑——该效率以每任期内受理案件数量与发布裁判意见数量为衡量标准。总体而言,本文的实证研究结果并未为上述主张提供明确支撑。



