Table 3 in Water quality, yield and cost-benefit analysis of rain water ponds of Cuttack district: A comparison between Indian major carp and GIFT Tilapia

Table 3: Comparision of operational cost, production and economic profit of IMC polyculture & GIFT mono-sex tilapia culture during 2018-19 at Jodamu village of district Ciuttack, Odisha
ParametersT1-IMC culture (area-.4 ha)T2-GIFT Tilapia culture (area-.4 ha)Operational CostExpenditure Expenditure (Rs/0.4ha/yr) (Rs/ha/yr)Expenditure (Rs/0.4ha/yr)Expenditure (Rs/ha/yr)I. ExpenditureWatering/de-watering charges3,0007,5003,0007,500Bleaching Powder 50kg@Rs30/kg1,5003,7501,5003,750Organic Manure 1000kg@Rs 0.5/kg5001,2505001,250DAP fertilizer 20kg@ 20/kg4001,0004001,000Lime-800kg (IMC), 1000kg (GIFT tilapia) @ Rs 10/kg8,00020,00010,00025,000GNOC-25kg (IMC), 42kg (GIFT tilapia) @ Rs 22/kg55013259242310Soyabin 21kg @Rs 30/kg6301,5756301,575Curd 120 kg @ 40/kg480012000480012000Yeast 5kg @ Rs 200/kg1000250010002500Ricebran 80kg @ Rs 15.5/kg1,2403,1001,2403,100Joggery-100kg (IMC), 208kg (GIFT tilapia) @ Rs 23/kg2,3005,7504,78411,960IMC seed4000pc @ Rs 5/pc and GIFT seed cost 6400pc @ Rs 2/pc20,00050,00012,80032,000IMC-F. Feed 5500kg @ Rs 40/kg and GIFT tilapia F. Feed 9800kg @ Rs 40/kg2,20,0005.50,0003,92,0009,80,000Transport @ Rs10000/time20,00050,00030,00075,000Man power for pond preparation, bio-security installation, Management, Feeding, 10,000 netting, watch and ward, marketing etc. @ 200/man day (IMC & GIFT)25,00030,00075,000Miscellaneous expenditure (medicine, aeration, transaction and coordination)5,00012,50010,00025,000Total expenditure2,98,9207,47,3005,03,57815,22,070IMC poly-culture & GIFT mono-sex tilapia Production and economic profit (2018-19)II. Gross Income from GIFT tilapia0.4 ha/yrha/yr0.4 ha/yrha/yrTotal production (kg/yr)33838457.5800020000IMC & GIFT Cost of fish @ Rs 160 & 140/kg (Rs)5,41,28013,53,30011,20,00028,00,000Net income from fish (Gross income-expenditure) (Rs)2,42,3606,05,9006,31,17215,77,930Return on expenditure (%)81.070.81125.33103.67Cost benefit ratio (C:B)0.8100.811.251.25