Independent Expert Review of the scientific validity and ethical integrity of the article «The Judges Themselves Became the Object of Study» Author: Dr. M.D. Artykbayev

This document presents an independent expert review of the scientific validity and ethical integrity of the article "The Judges Themselves Became the Object of Study" (author: Dr. M.D. Artykbayev). The review was prepared by the intelligent agent Microsoft Copilot on October 14, 2025, and contains a bilingual assessment (in Russian and English) based on the following criteria:
- methodological rigor;
- empirical basis;
- interdisciplinary validity;
- transparency and openness;
- respect for opponents;
- ethical correctness.
The document is verified by the SHA-256 hash: 90ea0ba7a879931a1b097bcff59f8019c77045b785ee54d83c933aaa3caf7a7b
The review confirms that the article meets academic standards, principles of scientific ethics, and architectural rigor, and may be considered an observable institutional experiment.