Differences in vocalisations, morphology and mtDNA support species status for New Zealand saddleback Philesturnus spp

Appropriate definitions of species limits are critical for scientific study and conservation management. Many subspecies of birds are defined on the basis of phenotypic variation. However, it has been suggested that following close examination many of these subspecies will be recognised as good species. North Island (NI) (Philesturnus rufusater) and South Island (SI) saddlebacks (P. carunculatus) differ in plumage and apparent vulnerability to introduced predators and, until recently, were considered subspecific. Here, we formally compare vocalisations, morphology and mtDNA between NI and SI saddlebacks. We show significant differences in male song and chatter calls which are fundamental saddleback vocalisations. A discriminant analysis correctly allocated 90% of birds based on significantly larger tarsus, weight and wing measurements in SI saddlebacks relative to NI saddlebacks. Finally, molecular data show c. 5% sequence divergence in mtDNA between the two groups. We concur with previous work elevating NI and SI saddleback to full species.