Agreement among reviewers regarding recommendations on the publication of evaluated manuscripts (N = all 529 possible reviewer pairs from 554 reviews on 206 manuscripts).

Cohen's kappa for this 3×3 cross table: 0.059 [95%-CI: −0.016–0.134], Spearman's r: 0.17 (p<0.0001). When “accept” and “accept after revision” were condensed into one variable indicating acceptance Cohen's kappa for the resulting 2×2 cross table was 0.16 [95%-CI: 0.059–0.252], Spearman's r: 0.16 (p = 0.0002).
*Designation of reviewers as ‘Reviewer 1’ or ‘Reviewer 2’ was arbitrary.

针对该3×3列联表（cross table）计算得到的科恩卡帕系数（Cohen's kappa）为0.059，95%置信区间（95%-CI）为−0.016至0.134；斯皮尔曼秩相关系数（Spearman's r）为0.17（p<0.0001）。当将“接收（accept）”与“返修后接收（accept after revision）”合并为一个表示“接收（acceptance）”的变量后，得到的2×2列联表的科恩卡帕系数为0.16，95%置信区间为0.059至0.252，斯皮尔曼秩相关系数为0.16（p=0.0002）。
*将审稿人标注为“审稿人1”或“审稿人2”仅为随机指定。