TABLE 1 in A new species of Brassica (Brassicaceae) from Bolkar Mountains (Türkiye) with morphological and molecular evidence

TABLE 1. Comparison of morphological characteristic of Brassica huseyin-duralii, B. elongata, and B. repanda with its subspecies. CharacteristicsÎStemLeaf sizeRosette leaf shapeLeaf hair typeNumber ofPetalSiliquaSiliquaTaxaÐlenghtflowerslenghtlenghtwideBrassica huseyin-duralii Başköse & Savran20–45 cm5.0–9.0 × 0.5–1.2 cmentire, oblog, oblong- eliptic, obovate or oblanseolate, rarely spatulatevery dense strigose hairy on both surfaces, hairs spreading or retrorse10 to 307.5–11.5 mm20–45 cm2.0–3.75 mmBrassica elnongata Ehrh. subsp.with tubercledelongata20–100 cm5.0–15.0 × 1.0–4.0 cmentire, oblong-ovate, sinuate-pinnatifid, oblaneolatecurved bristles on both sides or strigose to50 to 1505–10 mm10–45 mm1–2.5 mmglabrousBrassica repanda (Willd.) DC.(5–)12–(1–)2–15(–entire to pinnatisectglabrous3 to 357–30 mm15–801.5–5subsp. repanda60(–75) cm18) cmmmmmsubsp. africana [Maire (1929:30–60 cm2–16 ×pinnatifidhairy, at least on10 to 308–12 mm15–221.5–2.513)] Greuter & Burdet (1983:0.3–15.0the bordermmmm86)cmsubsp. almeriensis Gσmez-(5–)8–12(–2–3 ×subentire toloosely hispid2 to 89 mm20–252.0–2.5Campo (1976: 154)20) cm0.8–1.0pinnatifidmmmmcmsubsp. baldensis Prosser &30–60(–80)5–23 ×sinuate to pinnatifideblade surface15 to 3012–1630–703–5(–6)Bertolli (2007: 191)cm0.3–3.5glabrousmmmmmmcmsubsp. blancoana [Boissier50–75 cm(4–)8–sinuate to pinnatifid,glabrous or10 to 2010–1250–2.5–3.5(1854: 29)] Heywood (1962:12(–15) ×sometimessubglabrosmm80(100)mm153)1.5–2 cmpinnatipartedmmsubsp. cadevallii [Font Quer30–35 cm8–10 ×pinnatifid toglabrous or10 to 3010 mm40–603.5–4.0(1935: 72)] Heywood (1962:1–1.5 cmpinnatipartedsubglabrosmmmm154)subsp. cantabrica [Font Quer(10–) 20–354.5–8 ×pinnatipartite orglabrous or15 to 2510 mm25–353.0–4.0(1935: 73)] Heywood (1964:cm1.0–1.5pinnatisectloosely hairymmmm151)cmsubsp. confusa [Emberger &10–50 cm4–5 ×sinuate-dentate tohairy, at least on10 to 3010 mm25–501.5–2.5Maire (1941: 1007)] Heywood0.8–1.2pinnatifidthe bordermmmm(1962: 153)cmsubsp. dertosensis Molero &15–25 cm(7–)10 ×pinnatipartedglabrous5 to 2010-12(25–)30–(2–)2.5–Rovira (1988: 99)1.0–1.5mm50 (–60)3.5 (–4)cmmmmmsubsp. galissieri [Giraud (1892:30–40 cm6–10 ×pinnatipartiteglabrousup to 356–12 mm40–552.5–3.021)] Heywood (1964: 150)1.5–2.5mmmmcmsubsp. glabrescens Poldini10–25 cm2–9 ×mostly pinnatipartiteglabrous2 to 127–10 mm25–601.5–3.0(1973: 181) Gomez-Campo0.2–0.8mmmm(1998: 379)cmsubsp. gypsicola Gomez-Campo50–60 cm6–10 ×deeply pinnatehairy to densely15 to 2010–1235–652.0–3.0(1992: 145)1.0–1.5hairymmmmmmcmsubsp. latisiliqua [Boissier &(10–)20–352–4 ×entire or slightlyhispid8 to 2010 mm25–502.5–4.0Reuter (1854: 30)] Heywoodcm0.8–1.2toothed to pinnatifidmmmm(1962: 153)cmsubsp. maritima [Willkomm40–45 cm6–10 ×lobed or ± deeplyglabrous or20 to 3012–1540–604–5 mm(1885:141)] Heywood (1962:1.0–1.5(–pinnatifidsubglabrousmmmm153)2) cmsubsp. saxatilis Candolle2–16 cm4–10 ×usually pinnatipartiteglabrous or on2 to 108–15 mm20–502.0–2.5(1821b: 636) Heywood (1964:0.5–3.5the lacinia tipmmmm151)cmsubsp. silenifolia [Emberger15–30 cm5–12 ×entire, lanseolateglabrous5 to 15-40–503–5 mm(1936: 200)] Greuter & Burdet0.7–2.0mm(1983: 86)cmsubsp. turbonis [Montserrat10–15 cm3–4 × 0.8PinnatifidSetulous5 to 1010 mm30–452–3 mm(1953: 181)] J.M.Monts. &cmmmRomo (1985: 64)表1 胡塞因-杜拉利芸苔（Brassica huseyin-duralii）、长茎芸苔（B. elongata）及其亚种与波叶芸苔（B. repanda）各亚种的形态特征对比 | 类群 | 茎高 | 叶大小 | 莲座叶形态 | 叶毛类型 | 花数 | 花瓣长 | 长角果长 | 长角果宽 | |------|------|--------|------------|----------|------|--------|----------|----------| | 胡塞因-杜拉利芸苔（Brassica huseyin-duralii Başköse & Savran） | 20–45 cm | 5.0–9.0 × 0.5–1.2 cm | 全缘、倒卵形、长圆形、长圆状椭圆形、倒披针形，稀匙形 | 两面均被极密糙伏毛，毛平展或反折 | 10~30 | 7.5–11.5 mm | 20–45 cm | 2.0–3.75 mm | | 长茎芸苔（Brassica elongata Ehrh.） | 20–100 cm | 5.0–15.0 × 1.0–4.0 cm | 全缘、长圆状卵形、波状羽状浅裂、倒披针形 | 两面被弯曲刚毛或糙伏毛至无毛 | 50~150 | 5–10 mm | 10–45 mm | 1–2.5 mm | | 波叶芸苔原亚种（Brassica repanda (Willd.) DC. subsp. repanda） | (5–)12–60(–75) cm | (1–)2–18 cm | 全缘至羽状全裂 | 无毛 | 3~35 | 7–30 mm | 15–80 mm | 1.5–5 mm | | 波叶芸苔非洲亚种（subsp. africana [Maire (1929:30–86)] Greuter & Burdet (1983: 86)） | 30–60 cm | 2–15.0 cm | 羽状浅裂 | 被毛，至少叶缘具毛 | 10~30 | 8–12 mm | 15–22 mm | 1.5–2.5 mm | | 波叶芸苔阿尔梅里亚亚种（subsp. almeriensis Gomez-Campo (1976: 154)） | (5–)8–12(–20) cm | 2–3 × 0.8–1.0 cm | 近全缘至羽状浅裂 | 疏生硬毛 | 2~8 | 9 mm | 20–25 mm | 2.0–2.5 mm | | 波叶芸苔巴尔杜亚种（subsp. baldensis Prosser & Bertolli (2007: 191)） | 30–60(–80) cm | 5–23 × 0.3–3.5 cm | 波状至羽状浅裂 | 叶表面无毛 | 15~30 | 12–16 mm | 30–70 mm | 3–5(–6) mm | | 波叶芸苔布兰科亚种（subsp. blancoana [Boissier (1854: 29)] Heywood (1962: 153)） | 50–75 cm | (4–)8–12(–15) × 1.5–2 cm | 波状至羽状浅裂，偶羽状半裂 | 无毛或近无毛 | 10~20 | 10–12 mm | 50–80(–100) mm | 2.5–3.5 mm | | 波叶芸苔卡德瓦利亚种（subsp. cadevallii [Font Quer (1935: 72)] Heywood (1962: 154)） | 30–35 cm | 8–10 × 1–1.5 cm | 羽状浅裂至羽状半裂 | 无毛或近无毛 | 10~30 | 10 mm | 40–60 mm | 3.5–4.0 mm | | 波叶芸苔坎塔布里亚亚种（subsp. cantabrica [Font Quer (1935: 73)] Heywood (1964: 151)） | (10–)20–35 cm | 4.5–8 × 1.0–1.5 cm | 羽状半裂至羽状全裂 | 无毛或疏被毛 | 15~25 | 10 mm | 25–35 mm | 3.0–4.0 mm | | 波叶芸苔混淆亚种（subsp. confusa [Emberger & Maire (1941: 1007)] Heywood (1962: 153)） | 10–50 cm | 4–5 × 0.8–1.2 cm | 波状齿状至羽状浅裂 | 被毛，至少叶缘具毛 | 10~30 | 10 mm | 25–50 mm | 1.5–2.5 mm | | 波叶芸苔德尔托萨亚种（subsp. dertosensis Molero & Rovira (1988: 99)） | 15–25 cm | (7–)10 × 1.0–1.5 cm | 羽状半裂 | 无毛 | 5~20 | 10–12 mm | (25–)30–50(–60) mm | 2.5–3.5(–4) mm | | 波叶芸苔加利西耶尔亚种（subsp. galissieri [Giraud (1892: 21)] Heywood (1964: 150)） | 30–40 cm | 6–10 × 1.5–2.5 cm | 羽状半裂 | 无毛 | ≤35 | 6–12 mm | 40–55 mm | 2.5–3.0 mm | | 波叶芸苔淡褐毛亚种（subsp. glabrescens Poldini (1973: 181) Gomez-Campo (1998: 379)） | 10–25 cm | 2–9 × 0.2–0.8 cm | 多为羽状半裂 | 无毛 | 2~12 | 7–10 mm | 25–60 mm | 1.5–3.0 mm | | 波叶芸苔石膏土亚种（subsp. gypsicola Gomez-Campo (1992: 145)） | 50–60 cm | 6–10 × 1.0–1.5 cm | 深羽状裂 | 被毛至密被毛 | 15~20 | 10–12 mm | 35–65 mm | 2.0–3.0 mm | | 波叶芸苔宽长角果亚种（subsp. latisiliqua [Boissier & Reuter (1854: 30)] Heywood (1962: 153)） | (10–)20–35 cm | 2–4 × 0.8–1.2 cm | 全缘、微齿状至羽状浅裂 | 硬毛 | 8~20 | 10 mm | 25–50 mm | 2.5–4.0 mm | | 波叶芸苔滨海亚种（subsp. maritima [Willkomm (1885:141)] Heywood (1962: 153)） | 40–45 cm | 6–10 × 1.0–1.5(–2) cm | 浅裂或近深羽状浅裂 | 无毛或近无毛 | 20~30 | 12–15 mm | 40–60 mm | 4–5 mm | | 波叶芸苔岩生亚种（subsp. saxatilis Candolle (1821b: 636) Heywood (1964: 151)） | 2–16 cm | 4–10 × 0.5–3.5 cm | 通常羽状半裂 | 无毛或裂片顶端具毛 | 2~10 | 8–15 mm | 20–50 mm | 2.0–2.5 mm | | 波叶芸苔剪叶状亚种（subsp. silenifolia [Emberger (1936: 200)] Greuter & Burdet (1983: 86)） | 15–30 cm | 5–12 × 0.7–2.0 cm | 全缘、披针形 | 无毛 | 5~15 | 8–12 mm | 40–50 mm | 3–5 mm | | 波叶芸苔图尔博尼斯亚种（subsp. turbonis [Montserrat (1953: 181)] J.M.Monts. & Romo (1985: 64)） | 10–15 cm | 3–4 × 0.8 cm | 羽状浅裂 | 被微柔毛 | 5~10 | 10 mm | 30–45 mm | 2–3 mm |