Data from: Comparing cal3 and other a posteriori time-scaling approaches in a case study with the pterocephaliid trilobites
收藏资源简介:
Reconstructing the tree of life involves more than identifying relationships among lineages; it also entails accurately estimating when lineages diverged. Paleontologists typically scale cladograms to time a posteriori by direct reference to first appearances of taxa in the stratigraphic record. Some approaches use probabilistic models of branching, extinction, and sampling processes to date samples of trees, such as the recently developed cal3 method, which stochastically draws divergence dates given a set of rates for those processes. However, these models require estimates of the rates of those processes, which may be hard to obtain, particularly for sampling. Here, we contrast the use of cal3 and other a posteriori time-scaling approaches by examining a previous study that documented a decelerating rate of morphological evolution in pterocephaliid trilobites. Although aspects of the data set make estimation of branching, extinction, and sampling rates difficult, we use a multifaceted approach to calculate and evaluate the rate estimates needed for applying cal3. In agreement with previous simulation studies, we find that the choice of phylogenetic dating method impacts downstream macroevolutionary conclusions. We also find contradictory evolutionary inferences between analyses on ancestor–descendant contrasts (based on ancestor trait reconstruction methods) and maximum-likelihood parameter estimates. Ancestral taxon inference in cal3 corroborates previously hypothesized ancestor–descendant sequences, but cal3 suggests greater support for budding cladogenesis than anagenesis. This case study demonstrates the potential and wide applicability of the cal3 method and the benefits afforded by choosing cal3 over simpler a posteriori time-scaling approaches.
重建生命之树 (tree of life) 的核心任务不仅在于厘清各演化支系间的亲缘关系,更需要精准估算各支系的分化时点。古生物学家通常通过直接参照地层记录中分类单元 (taxa) 的首次出现数据,对分支系统树 (cladogram) 开展后验 (a posteriori) 时间校准。部分研究方法则借助分支、灭绝与采样过程的概率模型,对系统发育树样本进行定年,例如近期提出的cal3方法:该方法基于上述过程的一系列速率参数,随机推演各分化时间点。但这类模型需要先估算上述过程的速率参数,而这一步骤往往难度较大,尤其是采样速率的估算。本研究通过重新分析一项已发表的研究——该研究记录了翼头三叶虫类 (pterocephaliid trilobites) 的形态演化速率呈衰减趋势——对比了cal3方法与其他后验时间校准方法的应用效果。尽管本数据集的部分特征会给分支、灭绝与采样速率的估算带来挑战,但我们采用多维度分析框架,计算并评估了应用cal3方法所需的速率估算值。与此前的模拟研究结果一致,本研究发现:系统发育定年方法的选择会对后续的宏演化 (macroevolution) 研究结论产生显著影响。本研究同时发现,基于祖先-后裔对比分析 (ancestor–descendant contrasts,依托祖先性状重建 (ancestor trait reconstruction) 方法) 与最大似然 (maximum-likelihood) 参数估算得到的演化推论存在矛盾。cal3方法得到的祖先分类单元推断结果验证了此前提出的祖先-后裔演化序列假说,但该方法更支持出芽分支成种 (budding cladogenesis) 而非前进演化 (anagenesis)。本案例研究证实了cal3方法的应用潜力与广泛适用性,同时也表明相较于简易的后验时间校准方法,采用cal3方法能够带来更可靠的研究结果。



